In our ongoing search to find the best Sugar Daddy dating sites we present our SugarDaddyToday review to share our findings on Sugar Daddy Today. Using the criteria we lay out in our Best Sugar Daddy Website Review we take a deep look into SugarDaddyToday.com to find out if it is a site you should invest your time into or one you should avoid completely.
We would love to say otherwise but no no matter how you look at it, SugarDaddyToday.com is not worth your time. The first thing you’ll notice is that the SugarDaddyToday site is outdated. The initial pictures come straight out of 1993 and it looks like that is the last time that anything on the site was changed.
But we can look past the graphics and the SugarDaddyToday landing page boasts some impressive features: 100% FREE membership, full membership for all members, mail, and a place to mark all the “hotties”. Who can say no to full membership at no cost? Unfortunately there are some problem with that….
Before we dive into that lets look at the positives we found for SugarDaddyToday:
SugarDaddyToday Positive #1 – No ads, no spam, and no offsite marketing
Once you dig past all of the money confusion with SugarDaddyToday, there is one serious positive. There is no advertising anywhere on the site. Everywhere you would normally see an ad, there is a graphic advertising how great SugarDaddyToday is.
No advertising means no other ways that SugarDaddyToday could get money out of your pocket. The site doesn’t want to get you to purchase add ons, join a partner site, or pull you over to cam shows. That is always a good thing.
Sugar Daddy Today Positive #2 – It is easy to exchange offsite information if you find the right person.
SugarDaddyToday is very open about members being able to contact other people via phone, email, or IM. They don’t offer these options anywhere on the site. Unlike other sugar match websites, they will not block or erase contact information if you choose to share it.
Every profile on SugarDaddyToday actually has a direct contact section where you can include phone, Skype contacts, or email address. The site also will not make you pay to contact someone. These are definite perks if you are actually able to find someone compatible but with so few members, that’s not as easy as it should be.
SugarDaddyToday Problem #1 – This site is not free
SugarDaddyToday isn’t free. When you sign up, you have to immediately enter your Paypal account information – which is strange for a 100% free site. The next page will let you know that your first 10 days are free. After that it’s just $5 a month. If you go through with it, you’ll get an email telling you that you get 7 days free. Which means that you somehow lost three days and it makes the site seem like it’s just trying to get money out of its members with loopholes.
Sugar Daddy Today Problem #2 – Everyone has to pay
Having both sugar daddies AND babies pay for memberships just doesn’t make sense. Having both parties pay the same amount is even weirder. Are you looking for a man who can only pay $5 to meet you? Or a girl who will only give up $5 for the chance to be set up for the rest of her life? $5 a month doesn’t make sense.
It isn’t high enough to prove that either person is actually committed to finding the right person for them; it’s just high enough that you can keep paying for it month after month once you dump the site.
Once you’ve joined you have to wait up to 48 hours to be approved. We can’t really figure out what they’re approving – you have to enter almost no information when you sign up. Really all that SugarDaddyToday wants is your Paypal information. Then they give you dates that change.
Is the free trial 10 days or 7 days? Does it start the day I sign up or two days later when I’m approved? These questions aren’t answered anywhere (and we weren’t going to keep our profiles long enough to find out).
Sugar Daddy Today Problem #3 – The site allows girls who AREN’T interested in dating.
If you go through with making an account on SugarDaddyToday anyway and deal with the free trial – the second red flag is in the search menu. Not all the girls on the site are looking for a sugar daddy. Some are just models looking to have their careers launched. This isn’t bad on its own.
Finding a hot girl who is also a model who needs a companion would be great, but these girls say flat out that they just want money for their career. SugarDaddyToday is letting girls on who don’t even want to be a sugar baby. They also have sections for online only relationships and LGBT searches, if that’s more up your alley.
SugarDaddyToday Problem #4 – There are very few members.
Once you start searching SugarDaddyToday you’ll find out why they let anyone on: there are almost no members. The front page says that there are over 80,000 members but we could find no more than a few hundred. The search functions really well. You can people based on where they are or what type of physical preferences you have.
This makes finding what you like on SugarDaddyToday really easy but there is almost no one to choose from once you’ve entered your specifications. They let you enter really specific locations, not just metro areas, so there is also a very good chance that whoever you find is going to be nowhere near you if you aren’t careful.
Sugar Daddy Today Problem #5 – The member sections are sketchy and misleading
Beware of the “new members” section at the bottom of SugarDaddyToday. This includes some nice looking girls to draw you in but that list just rotates through ten or twelve members. It will seem like there are more sugar babies joining by the hour but when you log back in the next day, the same girls from yesterday will be posted and it will rotate through the selection again. Their process of adding girls seems to be broken or it’s just sketchy. Either way, you’ll want to ignore this section.
It makes sense that the new members keep rotating because the pickings are very slim on SugarDaddyToday. On the bright side, this means there are very few fake profiles. We were never directed offsite for cams or shows. There were no automatic responses to messages. When you interact with someone, you know it’s real. Unlike other sites, you don’t have to worry about wasting time talking to a spambot.
SugarDaddyToday Problem #6 – Once you find a girl, she probably won’t respond.
There are no bots to deal with but there are also very few members and the girls know it. We reached out to ten sugar babies under the age of 25 and only got one response in 24 hours. The response was also only three words. These girls know they’re in high demand and they are not going to respond to just any message. This would be a good place to test out your skills if you were feeling rusty. If you can get these girls to answer you, you can get anyone to do it.
Sugar Daddy Today Problem #7 – If you’re looking for a sugar daddy, don’t hold your breath
And if you’re looking for a sugar daddy? Look somewhere else. We got a cute little 23 year old sugar baby on the site to see if she could find the right man. We found out 50% of the daddies have no profile picture. 20% admit that they don’t have money and they’re just looking for “online fun”. The last 30% are spread out all over the world and most haven’t been active on the site in a long time. After 48 hours, our sugar baby only received SIX messages. That is absolutely unheard of for a babe on a dating site.
Once those messages came through, they were nothing to write home about. Most were just copied and pasted and clearly sent to every girl who popped up. The others immediately asked for phone numbers or a one night stand. No one ever made an effort to get to know our baby or to introduce themselves. The site would be passable if the few members were quality, but they weren’t.
SugarDaddyToday Problem #8 – The site’s features are outdated
Another quirk is the message system itself. It’s ancient. There’s no IMing here. There’s no place for quick, flirty chats. This messaging system is meant for long love letters. If that’s your style, you’re in luck. But if you’re not a poet and you prefer most fast-paced action, this is not the place for you. The site is only set up to send messages that are exactly line emails.
There is an inbox and outbox in the mailing system where you can see if someone has opened your message. This feature can only lead to bad news. Either they opened the message and didn’t respond or they haven’t been online and opened the message. There is no good outcome for the outbox (unless you like disappointment, in which case you might be better suited for a fetish site).
Sugar Daddy Today Problem #9 – Are they just trying to get our money?
Because they don’t care if you stay on the site, it starts to feel like they’re hoping that members set up the automatic payments and just forget about it. $5 doesn’t seem like much, but if they can get 1,000 members all sending that money monthly, for no effort in updating the site, they’ve created a lucrative business. The site can rake in money because most people can’t be bothered to figure out how to cancel to save the five bucks.
Is Sugar Daddy Today Legitimate: The Answer
SugarDaddyToday is good if you are not picky, willing to relocate (or help someone move), and you really like to write out love letters. Unfortunately it did not rate high enough to be included on our Best Sugar Daddy and Sugar Baby Websites Review.
SugarDaddyToday is not for you if you have more discerning tastes or if you want chat on the site before giving out contact information. If you want to find someone that you’re really compatible with, give a different site a try. There are better options out there to find the right match for you.